Halloween Memories and Peanut Butter Spiders

Peanut butter spider cookies with chocolate-ball bodies, candy eyes, and chocolate legs on a tray decorated with a white icing web.
End-of-Month Food Memory

Halloween Memories and Peanut Butter Spiders

Month October
The story

An October tradition and a favorite festive treat

Our Story

October always makes me a little nostalgic for Halloween when the girls were little. For quite a few years, a neighboring family invited us over for a Halloween party, and it became one of those traditions we looked forward to each fall.

Everyone brought appetizers and desserts, the kids had something to eat, and they ran around and played before groups headed out to trick-or-treat. The kids loved those parties and all the happy chaos of being together on Halloween. Then came the fun of coming back home, counting their candy, and sorting it into piles. We’d end the night with a little treat, stretching out the excitement just a bit longer.

I was always in charge of bringing a treat, which suited me perfectly. I love a good baked treat, and Halloween gave me an excuse to make it festive. Of all the things I brought over the years, my favorite was a batch of little peanut butter spider cookies.

They started with the peanut butter blossom cookies I usually make at Christmas: soft peanut butter cookies with that little crust of sugar on the outside. Instead of a Hershey’s Kiss, I pressed a milk chocolate ball into the center after baking. A couple of candy eyes and little legs made from melted chocolate turned each one into a spider. They were so cute, and the kids loved them. The adults did, too.

I think part of what I love about them is how easily a familiar cookie became something special for the occasion. A few little details made them feel right at home on the Halloween treat table, and they’re still the first treat I think of when I remember those parties.

This year, with our October post falling on Halloween, I wanted to share that memory. I love having a reason to gather with family or friends and bring something seasonal to the table. It doesn’t have to happen on the holiday itself. A little fall party a few days before Halloween, or even as October gives way to November, can be just as lovely. And if there happens to be a plate of peanut butter spiders, all the better.